IDEAS OF V.A. MAKLAKOV ON THE RUSSIAN AUTOCRACY IN THE LATE IMPERIAL PERIOD

DOI: 10.47026/2712-9454-2023-4-3-97-108

УДК 930(01)

ББК 63.3(2)

Elena L. SARAEVA

Key words

V.A. Maklakov, S.Yu. Witte, P.A. Stolypin, autocracy, liberalism in Russia, constitutional monarchy, basic state laws, Code of Laws of 1832

Abstract

The study of the role played by the autocracy of the late Imperial period in the history of Russia is relevant because it enables to understand the factors of its viability and its loss. Of considerable interest for the study of this topic are the judgments of contemporaries who knew the main political characters of that time, the goals and motives of their activities, domestic political circumstances. The novelty of the work lies in analysing the ideas of a liberal, a member of the Central Committee of the Cadet Party V.A. Maklakov, he gave a characteristics for the potential and weaknesses of the autocracy at the beginning of the XX century.

The purpose of the study is to interpret the representations of V.A. Maklakov about the autocracy’s responsibility for solving the problem of building relationships with the public, about the struggle of traditional and new forces in the Russian bureaucracy of the early XX century, the goals of their activities, their perception of autocracy, their attitude to the constitutional monarchy.

Materials and methods of the study. The sources on the topic are the texts of V.A. Maklakov: a recording of a lecture that he delivered in 1909 at Tinishevsky College, memoirs written in exile, legislative acts, and memoirs of contemporaries. The theoretical basis of the research is the theory of modernization, which characterizes the process of a traditional system’s transformation into a modern one; an axiological approach that focuses on the study of the value system; a civilizational concept that substantiates the idea of the people developing their cultural identity.

Study results. Maklakov characterized autocracy in the context of the ideas of legality and the right of the individual to freedom and self-determination. The Russian autocracy cared about the greatness of Russia, but the power of the monarch was not limited by laws. The idea of legality was present in the official ideology of the XIX – early XX century. Maklakov argued that the higher bureaucracy prevented the principle of legality from taking root in the country’s governance system. In the top leadership of the country, Maklakov singled out the “old” forces that defended the autocracy, and the “healthy elements” that solved promising national tasks of Russia’s development, they contributed to the transformation of an unlimited monarchy into a constitutional monarchy, defended the idea of interaction between the government and the society.

Conclusions. The autocracy proclaimed the principle of legality, but did not seek self-restraint by the constitution. The “historical power” was put on the path of constitutional development by statesmen who understood their duty to Russia. They sought to rely on liberal social forces, but the cadets did not support their program. According to Maklakov, after publishing the Manifest on October 17, 1905 and the Basic Laws of 1906, the Russian autocracy took the form of a “liberal autocracy”, since it was limited by the constitution, which created the mechanism for interaction between the government and the State Duma. Nicholas II made no further attempts to regain unlimited autocracy.

References

1. Dedkov N.I. Konservativnyi liberalizm Vasiliya Maklakova [The Conservative Liberalism of Vasily Maklakov]. Moscow, AIRO-HH Publ., 2005, 223 p.
2. Kokovcov V.N. Iz moego proshlogo. Vospominaniya. 1903–1919 gg.: v 2 kn. [From my past. Memories. 1903–1919. 2 books]. Moscow, Nauka Publ., 1992, book 1, 447 p.
3. Kocheshkov G.N., Saraeva E.L. Istoriko-kul’turnye istoki fevral’skogo revolyu-tsionnogo krizisa 1917 g.: idei liderov Progressivnogo bloka [Historical and cultural origins of the February revolutionary crisis of 1917: ideas of the leaders of the Progressive Bloc]. Dialog so vremenem, 2018, no. 65, pp. 300–317.
4. Maklakov V.A. Vlast’ i obshchestvennost’ na zakate staroi Rossii (Vospominaniya sovremennika) [The authorities and the public at the sunset of Old Russia (Memoirs of a contemporary)]. Paris, 1936, 610 p.
5. Maklakov V.A. Pervaya Gosudarstvennaya duma. Vospominaniya sovremennika. 27 ap-relya 1906 – 8 iyulya 1906 g. [The First State Duma. Memoirs of a contemporary. April 27, 1906 – July 8, 1906]. Moscow, Centr-poligraf Publ., 2006, 335 p.
6. Maklakov V.A. Zakonnost’ v russkoi zhizni [Legality in Russian life]. https://uchimsya.com/a/pN2S0GIW= (Access Date: 2023, Apt. 30).
7. Manifest 17 oktyabrya 1905 goda [Manifesto of October 17, 1905]. Rossiiskoe zakonodatel’stvo X–XX vv.: 9 t. [Russian legislation of the X–XX centuries. in 9 vols.]. Moscow, Yuridicheskaja literatura Publ., 1994, vol. 9, p. 41.
8. Osnovnye gosudarstvennye zakony 1906 g. [Basic State Laws of 1906]. Available at: https://constitution.garant.ru/history/act1600-1918/5207 (Access Date: 2023, Apt. 30).
9. Saraeva E.L. Vospriyatie kadetami Osnovnykh gosudarstvennykh zakonov v period raboty Pervoi Gosudarstvennoi dumy: idei V. A. Maklakova [Cadets’ Perception of the Main State Laws during the work of the First State Duma: V. A. Maklakov’s Ideas]. Vestnik Kostromskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta, 2021, vol. 27, no. 4, pp. 17–26.
10. Svod Osnovnykh gosudarstvennykh zakonov 1832 g. [The Code of Basic State Laws of 1832]. Available at: http://muzejreform.rf/node/13651 (Access Date: 2023, Apt. 30).

Information about the author

Elena L. Saraeva – Doctor of Historical Sciences, Associate Professor, Department of Russian History, Yaroslavl State Pedagogical University named after K.D. Ushinsky, Russia, Yaroslavl (els 5656@yandex.ru; ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0001-6140-7806).

For citations

Saraeva E.L. IDEAS OF V.A. MAKLAKOV ON THE RUSSIAN AUTOCRACY IN THE LATE IMPERIAL PERIOD. Historical Search, 2023,  vol. 4, no. 3, pp. 97–108. DOI: 10.47026/2712-9454-2023-4-3-97-108 (in Russian).

Download the full article