CHUVASH-RUSSIAN RELATIONS AND CONTACTS IN THE SECOND HALF OF THE XIX – EARLY XX CENTURY IN THE WORKS OF V.D. DIMITRIEV OF THE SOVIET PERIOD

DOI: 10.47026/2712-9454-2024-5-4-41-50

УДК 94(470.344)”18/19″

ББК 63.3(2Рус.Чув)5

Gennady A. NIKOLAEV

Key words: historiography, V.D. Dimitriev, Chuvash-Russian relations, seasonal work, cultural influence, household activities and everyday life, capitalism.

Vasily Dimitrievich Dimitriev, who by his fundamental works inscribed his name in the cohort of outstanding scientists of the Volga-Urals, was a deeply national historian. With that said, it seems relevant to clarify his views on the relations and contacts of the Chuvash and the Russians in the second half of the XIX – early XX century. In the regional literature, this issue is addressed only in the most general terms.

The purpose of the study is to provide a detailed historiographical analysis of the historian’s works on the outlined issues published by him during the Soviet period.

Materials and methods. This publication analyzes the essay, the article and the brochure written by V.D. Dimitriev before 1991, which relatively fully reflected his position on the topic under consideration. The study was carried out on the basis of using the systematic, historical-comparative and historical-anthropological methods.

Research results. V.D. Dimitriev devoted a number of works to the topic of Chuvash-Russian relations and contacts in the Soviet times, which differ significantly from each other in the form of material presentation. A panoramic picture of the relationship between representatives of two ethnic communities, appearing from the essay «Communication of the Chuvash with the Russians and the influence of the Russian culture on the Chuvash one in the late XIX – early XX centuries» (1968), is based on the testimonies and observations of the villagers. The essay is distinguished by its pronounced factual character. Based on reports from local correspondents, ethnographic essays and notes from contemporaries, in the context of individual localities, the author shows the contacts of Chuvash and Russian peasants in the Chuvash region at the turn of the XIX–XX centuries, qualifying them as friendly. At the same time, he identifies populated areas where ethnic partners were somewhat wary of each other. Strengthening of capitalist relations in the countryside, seasonal work, commercial and industrial activities of peasants, progress in the development of school education are considered in the publication as channels that stimulated assimilation of the Russian language by the Chuvash, the influence of Russian material and spiritual culture on the Chuvash way of life, economy and behavioral stereotype. In the article he wrote, «I.Ya. Yakovlev – a proponent of peoples rapprochement» (1969) the author’s analytical statements concerning contacts between the Chuvash and the Great Russians were reflected mainly indirectly, through the optics of analyzing the worldview and practical activities of the Chuvash teacher I.Ya. Yakovlev. The main socio-cultural components of Chuvash-Russian relations in the era of market relations are briefly shown in the brochure «Forever with the Russian people» (1976). Structurally, the material presented in it by the author serves as an information and analytical bridge connecting the realities of different historical eras into a single whole.

Conclusions. The works written by V.D. Dimitriev in the Soviet time on the topic of Chuvash-Russian relations and contacts, which are not free from the ideology of the Soviet era, are executed in a classical manner and represent a methodologically verified, well-structured sample of a scientific product, which in its basic provisions continues to remain modern and in demand by the scientific audience today.

References

1. Archbishop Arseny. Programma istoriko-statisticheskogo opisaniya tserkvei i prikhodov, soborov i monastyrei [The program of historical and statistical description of churches and parishes, cathedrals and monasteries]. Izvestiya po Kazanskoi eparkhii, 1899, no. 1, pp. 4–12.
2. Demidova I.I. Russko-chuvashskie svyazi vo vtoroi polovine XIX – nachale XX v. [Russian-Chuvash relations in the second half of the XIX – early XX century]. Cheboksary, Chuvash University Publ., 2006, 204 p.
3. Dimitriev V.D. Istoriya Chuvashii XVIII veka. (Do Krest’yanskoi voiny 1773–1775 godov.) [History of Chuvashia of the XVIII century (Before the Peasant War of 1773–1775.)]. Cheboksary, Chuvash Publ. House, 1959, 530 p.
4. Dimitriev V.D. Naveki s russkim narodom. K 425-letiyu dobrovol’nogo vkhozhdeniya Chuvashii v sostav Russkogo gosudarstva [Forever with the Russian people. To mark the 425^th anniversary of the voluntary entry of Chuvashia into the Russian state]. Cheboksary, Chuvash Publ. House, Publ., 1976, 79 p.
5. Dimitriev V.D. Obshchenie chuvashei s russkimi i vliyanie russkoi kul’tury na chuvashskuyu v kontse XIX – nachale XX vekov [Communication of Chuvash with Russians and the influence of Russian culture on Chuvash in the late XIX – early XX centuries]. In: Dimitriev V.D. Voprosy etnogeneza, etnografii i istorii kul’tury chuvashskogo naroda: sb. statei [Questions of ethnogenesis, ethnography and history of culture of the Chuvash people: coll. articles]. Cheboksary, Chuvash University Publ., 2004, pp. 279–309.
6. Dimitriev V.D. Obshchenie chuvashei s russkimi i vliyanie russkoi kul’tury na chuvashskuyu v kontse XIX – nachale XX vekov [Communication of the Chuvash with Russians and the influence of Russian culture on the Chuvash at the end of the XIX – early XX centuries]. In: Uchenye zapiski ChNII [Scientific notes of the Chuvash Scientific Research InstituteI]. Cheboksary, Chuvash Publ. House, 1968, iss. 11, pp. 103–128.
7. Dimitriev V.D. Pomoshch’ Sovetskogo gosudarstva i russkogo naroda trudyashchimsya Chuvashii v bor’be s golodom 1921–1922 gg. [Assistance of the Soviet state and the Russian people to the workers of Chuvashia in the fight against famine of 1921–1922]. In: Zapiski ChNII [Notes of the CHNII]. Cheboksary, Chuvash Publ. House, 1950, iss. 4, pp. 3–42.
8. Dimitriev V.D. Pravda o predposylkakh i protsesse mirnogo, po chelobit’yu, prisoedineniya Chuvashii k Rossii [The truth about the prerequisites and the process of peaceful, by petition, annexation of Chuvashia to Russia]. Izvestiya Natsional’noi akademii nauk i iskusstv Chuvashskoi Respubliki, 2000, no. 3; 2001, no. 1, pp. 3–83.
9. Dimitriev V.D.Ya. Yakovlev – pobornik sblizheniya narodov [I.Ya. Yakovlev – a champion of the rapprochement of peoples]. In: Uchenye zapiski ChNII [Scientific notes of the Central Research Institute]. Cheboksary, 1969, iss. 42, pp. 30–46.
10. Boyko I.I., ed., Nikolaev A., comp. Dimitriev Vasilii Dimitrievich: uchenyi, pedagog, obshchestvennyi deyatel’, grazhdanin [Dimitriev Vasily Dimitrievich: scientist, teacher, public figure, citizen: collection of articles]. Cheboksary, 2013, 252 p.
11. Istoriya Chuvashii cherez prizmu kompleksnogo podkhoda: ot mezhdistsiplinarnosti k transdistsiplinarnosti: sb. materialov Vseros. nauch.-prak. konf., posv. 100-letiyu so dnya rozhdeniya Vasiliya Dimitrievicha Dimitrieva [Proc. of Rus. Sci. Conf. «The history of Chuvashia through the prism of an integrated approach: from interdisciplinarity to transdisciplinarity»]. Cheboksary, Chuvash University Publ., 2024, 424 p.
12. Kappeler A. Vospominaniya [Memories]. In: Boyko I.I., ed., Nikolaev A., comp. Dimitriev Vasilii Dimitrievich: uchenyi, pedagog, obshchestvennyi deyatel’, grazhdanin [Dimitriev Vasily Dimitrievich: scientist, teacher, public figure, citizen: collection of articles]. Cheboksary, 2013, pp. 155–158.
13. Nikolsky N.V. Programma dlya sobiraniya svedenii o chuvashakh [A program for collecting information about the Chuvash]. Izvestiya po Kazanskoi eparkhii, 1904, no. 3, pp. 63–72.
14. Sluzhenie istorii [Service to history: collection of articles]. Cheboksary, Chuvash University Publ., 2005, iss. 1, 198 p.
15. Sluzhenie istorii [Service to history: collection of articles]. Cheboksary, Chuvash University Publ., 2008, iss. 2, 316 p.
16. Froyanov I.Ya., Smirnov Yu.P. Istorik, issledovatel’, uchenyi V.D. Dimitriev [Historian, researcher, scientist V.D. Dimitriev]. Cheboksary, Chuvash University Publ., 1994, 68 p.

About the author

Gennady A. Nikolaev – Candidate of Historical Sciences, Russia, Cheboksary (nicga50@rambler.ru; ORCID: https://orcid.org/0009-0000-1443-545X).

For citations

Nikolaev G.A. CHUVASH-RUSSIAN RELATIONS AND CONTACTS IN THE SECOND HALF OF THE XIX – EARLY XX CENTURY IN THE WORKS OF V.D. DIMITRIEV OF THE SOVIET PERIOD. Historical Search, 2024, vol. 5, no. 4, pp. 41–50. DOI: 10.47026/2712-9454-2024-5-4-41-50 (in Russian).

Download the full article