CRITICS AND ILL-WILLERS IN THE FATE OF THE CHUVASH EDUCATOR I.Ya. YAKOVLEV

DOI: 10.47026/2712-9454-2023-4-3-5-11

УДК 37(092)Яковлев

ББК Ч33(2Рос.Чув)5-8Яковлев

Tatyana N. IVANOVA

Key words

I.Ya. Yakovlev, criticism of his “separatism”, “counterrevolution”, “Russification”

Abstract

The article highly appreciates the importance of the activities carried out by the Chuvash educator Ivan Yakovlevich Yakovlev. However, the author believes that without analyzing the difficulties, obstacles and attacks of slanderers that the great educator of the Chuvash people had to go through, the scale of his personality and his perseverance in achieving his goal cannot be worthily appreciated. That is why it is important to remember those facts of his biography that give the opportunity to understand the historical situation in which I.Ya. Yakovlev had to act.

The purpose of the article is to consider the main facts from the biography of I.Ya. Yakovlev, testifying to the desire of ill-willers to hinder the great educator in his noble activities, which forced him to distract from pressing matters in order to resist undeserved criticism.

Materials and methods. The methodological basis of the article is made by the principles of historicism, objectivity and consistency, as well as a set of general scientific and special historical research methods that made it possible to conduct a comprehensive analysis of archival and memoir sources.

Study results. At the beginning of his activity I.Ya. Yakovlev was criticized as a follower of N.I. Ilminsky, and was accused of separatism and nationalism. After the revolution of 1905–1907, a slanderous campaign in the press began, aimed at reducing his authority among the Chuvash, which was associated with Yakovlev’s anti-revolutionary position. In 1917–1919, he was accused of a counterrevolutionary character, the All-Russian Special Commission for Combating Counter-revolution opened a case against him, Sabotage and Speculation and he was forced to resign from the post of inspector at Simbirsk Chuvash school. In 1922 Yakovlev was forced to leave Simbirsk. In the 1930s, he was accused of Russification and excessive religiosity. “Yakovlevism” was declared a negative phenomenon in the Chuvash culture. It was only in the late 1940s that an objective assessment of I.Ya. Yakovlev’s enormous contribution to the education of the Chuvash people came to the fore.

Conclusions. During his long life, I.Ya. Yakovlev was accused of separatism, nationalism, counterrevolutionary activities, and russification. After some time, these accusations look unfounded. He stood up, and today Ivan Yakovlevich is a recognized patriarch whose merits to the Chuvash people are beyond doubt. Paying tribute to these merits, one should not forget what difficulties, bad-mouthing and attacks of slanderers he went through on the way to his noble goal of educating the Chuvash people.

References

1. Arkhiv Rossiiskoi Akademii nauk. Fond 665. Opis’. 1. Dokument 182 [Archive of the Russian Academy of Sciences. Archives. 665. Anagraph. Document. 182].
2. Dimitriev V.D. Prosvetitel’ chuvashskogo naroda I.Ya. Yakovlev [Enlightener of the Chuvash people I.Ya. Yakovlev]. Cheboksary, Chuvash State University Publ., 2002, 140 p.
3. Dokumental’nyi fond Chuvashskogo natsional’nogo muzeya. Fond. 700. P. no 2 ChKM 1013/6 List 1-2 [Documentary Fund of the Chuvash National Museum. 700. P. no. 2 ChKM 1013/6 P.1-2].
4. Zhirkevich A.V. Pamyatnik (1919 g., podrazhanie stikhotvoreniyu A.S. Pushkina «Pamyatnik») [Monument (1919, imitation of A.S. Pushkin’s poem «Monument»)]. In: Gosudarstvennyi istoricheskii arkhiv Chuvashskoi Respubliki: Istoriya i kharakteristika dokumentov lichnogo fonda I.Ya. Yakovleva [State Historical Archive of the Chuvash Republic: History and characteristics of documents of the personal fund]. Available at: http://www.gia.archives.21ru/vystavki/Yakovlev/foto/stin/stin1.htm (Accessed Date: 2019, Oct. 5).
5. Ivanova T.N., Pushina A.P. Novye istochniki ob organizatsionno-prepodavatel’skoi deyatel’nosti Alekseya Ivanovicha Yakovleva v Simbirske (k publikatsii pis’ma I.S. Stepanova) [New sources on the organizational and teaching activities of Alexei Ivanovich Yakovlev in Simbirsk (to the publication of I.S. Stepanov’s letter)]. In: Paradigmy rossiiskoi istorii skvoz’ prizmu biografistiki (k 140-letiyu Alekseya Ivanovicha Yakovleva): materialy Vseros. nauchn. konf. s mezhd. uchas [Proc. of Russ. Sci. Conf. «Paradigms of Russian history through the prism of biographical studies (to the 140^th anniversary of Alexei Ivanovich Yakovlev»]. Cheboksary, Sreda Publ., 2019, pp. 58–62.
6. Ivanova T.N., Dmitrieva O.O. Sokhranenie naslediya I.Ya. Yakovleva i ego sem’i v ChGU im. I.N. Ul’yanova [Preservation of the heritage of I.Ya. Yakovlev and his family at the ChGU im.N. Ulyanova]. In: Paradigmy universitetskoi istorii i perspektivy universitetologii (k 50-letiyu Chuvashskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta imeni I.N. Ul’yanova): sb. st.: v 2 t. [Paradigms of university history and perspectives of university studies (to the 50^th anniversary of the Chuvash State University named after I.N. Ulyanov): Collection of articles. In 2 vol.]. Cheboksary, Sreda Publ., 2017, vol. 2, pp. 29–33.
7. Krasnov N.G. Ivan Yakovlev i ego potomki [Ivan Yakovlev and his descendants]. Cheboksary, Chuvash House, 2007, 480 p.
8. Mineeva E.K. Stanovlenie Mariiskoi, Mordovskoi i Chuvashskoi ASSR kak natsional’no-territorial’nykh avtonomii (1920–1930-e gody): dis. … d-ra ist. nauk [Formation of the Mari, Mordovian and Chuvash Autonomous Soviet Socialist Republics as national-territorial autonomies (1920–1930s). Diss.]. Cheboksary, 2008, 534 p.
9. Nauchno-issledovatel’skii otdel rukopisei Rossiiskoi gosudarstvennoi biblioteki. Fond. 361. K. 5. Dokument 1. Sergievskii. «Zapiska po povodu sudebnykh del I.Ya. Yakovleva v 1908 i 1909 godu». 10 listov [Research Department of Manuscripts of the Russian State Library. 361. K. 5. Document 1. Sergievsky. «A note on the court cases of I.Ya. Yakovlev in 1908 and 1909». 10 p.].
10. Nauchno-issledovatel’skii otdel rukopisei RGB. Fond. 361. K. 8. Edinitsa khraneniya 1. Yakovlev A.I.. «I.Ya. Yakovlev». 1947. 135 listov [Research Department of Manuscripts of the RSL. 361. K. 8. Storing Unite 1. Yakovlev A.I.. «I.Ya. Yakovlev». 1947. 135 p.].
11. Efirova A.F. Rusifikatorskaya sistema Il’minskogo v Chuvashii [Russification system of Ilminsky in Chuvashia]. Prosveshchenie natsional’nostei, 1935, no. 3, pp. 65–71.
12. Yakovlev I.Ya. Vospominaniya [Memories]. Moscow, Respublika, 1997, 696 p.

Information about the author

Tatyana N. Ivanova – Doctor of Historical Sciences, Professor of the Department of History and Culture of Foreign Countries, Chuvash State University. Russia, Cheboksary (tivanovan@mail.ru; ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0003-2428-2578).

For citations

Ivanova T.N. CRITICS AND ILL-WILLERS IN THE FATE OF THE CHUVASH EDUCATOR I.Ya. YAKOVLEV. Historical Search, 2023,  vol. 4, no. 3, pp. 5–11. DOI: 10.47026/2712-9454-2023-4-3-5-11 (in Russian).

Download the full article