«THE STATE» AND «LEGALITY» IN THE DISCOURSE OF P.A. STOLYPIN DURING THE REVOLUTIONARY CRISIS OF 1905–1907

DOI: 10.47026/2712-9454-2024-5-1-74-84

УДК 930(01)

ББК 63.3(2)

Elena L. SARAEVA

Key words

P.A. Stolypin, V.A. Maklakov, The State Duma of the Russian Empire, Nicholas II, military field courts, the revolution of 1905-1907, the constitutional Democratic Party, the constitutional monarchy in Russia, the Russian state of the early twentieth century, legality.

Abstract

The relevance of the research is determined by the need to disclose the political and legal concepts used by P.A. Stolypin during the first Russian Revolution and the beginning of forming the constitutional political system in Russia. Solving this problem makes it possible to better understand the ideas of the Chairman of the Council of Ministers, who played a significant role in developing the government’s reform program during the first Russian Revolution, and assess its compliance with historical time.

The novelty of the research lies in studying the influence of historical circumstances on P.A. Stolypin’s ideological design of the course aimed at creating a state governed by the rule of law, as well as at identifying its political values, which determined the main tasks of its activities.

The purpose of the study is to study the influence of historical circumstances on the ideological justification of P.A. Stolypin’s state activities during the years of the revolutionary crisis and transformation of the political system in Russia, in the analysis of his political discourse.

Materials and methods of the study. The source base of the work was made up of speeches by P.A. Stolypin and deputies of the State Duma in 1906–1907. The work is carried out in the context of the theory of political modernization and the axiological approach, which obliges to identify the system of values that determined the worldview of a historical personality.

Study results. In the new Russian historical conditions – the beginning of creating a constitutional state, arbitrariness of left–wing parties, criticism of government policy by Constitutional Democrats – the «healthy forces» in power actualized the task of creating the rule of law, offering their own version of its functioning: representative institutions are engaged in legislative work within their powers and recognize the prerogatives of the emperor. There was there is much concern about the authorities’ choice of means to combat to preserve the statehood and order. In Stolypin’s understanding, the priorities of the government should be to restore order in the interests of all compatriots. He disagreed with the liberals’ view that the government sought to govern on the basis of «exceptional laws,» saying that it was the duty of the authorities to preserve order. The government must fight destructive forces with all measures,» therefore, Stolypin believed, the government can resort to extraordinary means to prevent destruction of statehood and seizure of power by rebels.

Conclusions. The formation of the political discourse of the Prime Minister Stolypin was influenced by such historical circumstances as creation of a constitutional political system in 1905–1906, emergence of «healthy forces» in power capable of carrying out reforms, the activities of liberal parties demanding the rule of law, activation of a left-wing radical movement focused on destruction of the existing system. Stolypin thought through and ideologically justified the program, which was based on indisputable national values: integrity and greatness of Russia, strong statehood, legality, welfare and education of people, preservation of culture created by many generations of ancestors. Stolypin’s discourse was defined by the era of transition from autocracy to the rule of law, when a conflict arose between the value system of traditionalists, liberals and radicals. Maneuvering, Stolypin simultaneously formed the ideological foundations of the rule of law and protection of the management system by repressive means.

References

1. Izbrannye vystupleniya deputatov Gosudarstvennoi dumy s 1906 goda do nashikh dnei [Selected speeches of deputies of the State Duma from 1906 to the present day]. Moscow, State Duma Publ., 2013, 302 p.
2. Maklakov V.A. O zakonoproekte ob otmene voenno-polevykh sudov [On the draft law on the abolition of military field courts]. In: Izbrannye vystupleniya deputatov Gosudarstvennoi dumy s 1906 goda do nashikh dnei [Selected speeches of the deputies of the State Duma from 1906 to the present day]. Moscow, State Duma , 2013, p 22–25.
3. Maklakov V.A. Vlast’ i obshhestvennost’ na zakate staroj Rossii (Vospominanija sovremennika) [The authorities and the public at the sunset of Old Russia (Memoirs of a contemporary)]. Parizh, 1936, 610 p.
4. Maklakov V.A. Vtoraya Gosudarstvennaya duma. Vospominaniya sovremennika. 27 aprelya 1906 – 8 iyulya 1906 g. [The First State Duma. Memoirs of a contemporary. April 27, 1906 – July 8, 1906]. Moscow, Centr-poligraf Publ., 2006, 335 p.
5. Osnovnye gosudarstvennye zakony 1906 g. [Basic State Laws of 1906]. Available at: https://constitution.garant.ru/history/act1600-1918/5207/=(Access Date: 2023, Apt. 30).
6. Purishkevich V.M. O zakonoproekte ob otmene voenno-polevykh sudov [On the draft law on the abolition of military field courts]. In: Izbrannye vystupleniya deputatov Gosudarstvennoi dumy s 1906 goda do nashikh dnei [Selected speeches of the deputies of the State Duma from 1906 to the present day]. Moscow, State Duma , p. 21.
7. Svod Osnovnykh gosudarstvennykh zakonov 1832 g. [The Code of Basic State Laws of 1832]. URL: http://muzeireform.rf/node/13651= ( Available at:2023, 30).
8. Stolypin P.A. Nam nuzhna Velikaya Rossiya… [We need a Great Russia…]. In: Polnoe sobranie rechei v Gosudarstvennoi dume i Gosudarstvennom sovete. 1906–1911 gg. [A Complete Collection of Speeches in the State Duma and the State Council. 1906–1911]. Moscow, Molodaya gvardiya Publ., 1991, 411 p.
9. Utenkov G.N. Ideologiya gosudarstvennoi reformy P.A. Stolypina [A. Stolypin’s Ideology of State reform]. Vestnik Povolzhskogo instituta upravleniya, 2012, no. 2(31), pp. 5–10.
10. Forestetskii M.S. A. Stolypin i ideya pravovogo gosudarstva [P.A. Stolypin and the idea of the rule of law]. Problemy prava, 2014, no. 4(47), pp. 83–86.
11. Forestetskii M.S. Politiko-pravovye vzglyady P.A. Stolypina: … kand. yur. nauk [Political and legal views of P.A. Stolypin. Abstract of Cand. Diss.]. Belgorod, 2015, 23 p.
12. Wartenweiler D. Civil Society and Academic Debate in Russia 1905–1914. New York, 1999, 252 p.

Information about the author

Elena L. Saraeva – Doctor of Historical Sciences, Associate Professor, Department of Russian History, Yaroslavl State Pedagogical University named after K.D. Ushinsky, Russia, Yaroslavl (els5656@yandex.ru; ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0001-6140-7806).

For citations

Saraeva E.L. «THE STATE» AND «LEGALITY» IN THE DISCOURSE OF P.A. STOLYPIN DURING THE REVOLUTIONARY CRISIS OF 1905–1907. Historical Search, 2024, vol. 5, no. 1, pp. 74–84. DOI: 10.47026/2712-9454-2024-5-1-74-84 (in Russian).

Download the full article