THE PROBLEM OF INFORMATION VALUE OF CONFESSIONAL STATEMENTS IN HISTORICAL LITERATURE

Anzhelika N. Evdokimova

DOI: 10.47026/1810-1909-2021-2-55-63

Key words

confessional statements, Christianization, the Russian Orthodox Church, historiography, historical source.

Annotation

The article considers the achievements of modern Russian historiography in the field of compiling documents for demographic census registration by the parish Orthodox clergy in the synodic period of the Russian Orthodox Church. Among the problems that have been the most reflected, especially in the regional historiography of recent decades are the external features of confessional statements, changes in their forms during the XVIII–XIX centuries, the estates groups and strata represented in them, changes in the composition of parish families over several years, the gender and age composition of parishioners, migration processes within a one particular locality. The greatest value undoubtedly is the statistical data on the performance of Christian sacraments of confession and communion by parishioners. The works of researchers who analyze and use ecclesiastical signed documents, note a huge information potential of this type of historical sources. Ecclesiastical signed documents reveal not only the peculiarities in the social structure of an individual parish, diocese or eparchy as a whole. They are a fairly reliable indicator of the population’s introduction to the Orthodox faith and rites, especially beginning from the early XIX century, when the possibilities of data falsification by the parish clergy were minimized. This type of mass sources, such as signed documents, makes it possible to consider the history of everyday life, household and housing conditions, the distance of the village to the temple. The revealed shortcomings in ecclesiastical signed documents include the following: fixing the population only present in the parish, giving amorphous reasons for non-fulfillment of the sacraments such as “failure”, “negligence”, inaccurate determination of parishioners’ age in remote parish villages, real attitude of believers to the church and dogmas.

References

1. Akol’zina M.K, Morozova E.A. Ispovednye vedomosti gorodskikh i sel’skikh tserkvei kak istochnik po sotsial’noi istorii Tambovskoi gubernii pervoi poloviny XIX v. [Confessions of urban and rural churches as a source of social history of the Tambov province of the first half of the 19^th century]. In: Materialy tserkovnoprikhodskogo ucheta naseleniya Rossii kak istoriko-demograficheskii istochnik: sbornik statei [Materials of the church-coming accounting of the population of Russia as a historical and demographic source: collection of scientific articles]. Barnaul, Altaisk University Publ., 2007, pp. 121–126.
2. Akol’zina M.K., Sytin D.A. Dukhovenstvo v sostave naseleniya provintsial’nogo goroda Rossii v pervoi polovine XIX veka [The Clergy as Part of the Population of a Provincial Town in Russia in the First Half of the 19^th Century]. Bogoslavskii sbornik Tambovskoi dukhovnoi seminarii, 2019, iss. 8, pp. 46–57.
3. Asochakova V.N. Stanovlenie Russkoi pravoslavnoi tserkvi v Khakassko-Minusinskom krae v XVIII – pervoi chetverti XIX v. [The Formation of the Russian Orthodox Church in the Khakass-Minu-sinsk Region in the 18^th the Beginning of the 19^th Centuries]. Izvestiya Altaiskogo gosudar­stvennogo universiteta, 2009, no. 4-1(64), pp. 20–24.
4. Asochakova V.N. Tserkovnye istochniki demograficheskogo ucheta v izuchenii khristianizatsii korennykh narodov Sibiri [Church sources of demographic accounts when studying the Christianization of indigenous peoples of Siberia]. Problemy sotsial’no-ekonomicheskogo razvitiya Sibiri, 2016, no. 3(25), pp. 87–92.
5. Bilotas V. Katoliki Yuzhnoi Sibiri i Tsentral’noi Azii: mesta prozhivaniya i chislennost’ soglasno tserkovnym registram vtoroi poloviny XIX v. [The Roman Catholics of South Siberia and Central Asia: residences and number according to ecclesiastical registers of the second half of 19^th century]. Mirovozzrenie naseleniya Yuzhnoi Sibiri i Tsentral’noi Azii v istoricheskoi retrospective, 2016, no. 9, pp. 182–192.
6. Vasina T.A. Dukhovnye rospisi kak istochnik po istorii sem’i naseleniya Pudemskogo zavoda kontsa XVIII – nachala XIX v. [The Lists of Parishioners” Families are Documents of the Families History of the Pudem Factory Population in the late 18^th – early 19^th Centuries]. Vestnik Vyatskogo gosudarstvennogo gumanitarnogo universiteta, 2015, no. 12, pp. 67–73.
7. Vladimirov V.N., Sarafanov D.E. Istochnikovye osobennosti ispovednykh vedomostei Barnaul’­sko­go dukhovnogo pravleniya XIX v. [The sources of the confessions of the Barnaul spiritual rule of the 19^th century]. In: Dokument. Arkhiv. Istoriya. Sovremennost’: materialy IV Mezhdunar. nauch.-prakt. konf., posvyashchennoi 20-letiyu podgotovki dokumentovedov v Ural’skom federal’nom universitete [Proc. of 4^th Int. Sci. Conf. «Document. Archive. History. Modernity»]. Ekaterinburg, 2012, pp. 206–211.
8. Golikova S.V. Demograficheskii potentsial krest’yanskogo khozyaistva Zaural’ya (na primere Baklanovskoi volosti Shadrinskogo uezda kontsa XVIII veka) [Demographic potential of the peasantry of Sauralia (in the example of the Baklanovsky parish of Shadrin county of the late 18^th century)]. Vestnik arkheologii, antropologii, etnografii, 2016, no. 6, pp. 188–193.
9. Evdokimova A.N. Ispovednye vedomosti kak istoricheskii istochnik o sotsial’nom sostave prikhozhan chuvashskikh prikhodov Kazanskoi gubernii kontsa XVIII – pervoi poloviny XIX veka [Confessional Statements as a Historical Source of Church Members’ Social Structure in Chuvash Parishes of Kazan Governorate at the end of the 18^th – First Half of the 19^th Centuries]. Vestnik Chuvashskogo universiteta, 2019, no. 2, pp. 35–44.
10. Zamura E.Yu. Pravoslavnoe naselenie Pereyaslassko-Borispol’skoi eparkhii v usloviyakh rasprostraneniya epidemii chumy 1770–1771 gg. [The Orthodox population of the Pereialas-Borispol diocese in the midst of the spread of the plague epidemic of 1770–1771]. Kraeznavstvo, 2011, no. 1-1, pp. 144–151.
11. Krylova A.A. Dokumenty tserkovnogo ucheta naseleniya v kontekste genealogicheskoi kul’tury russkogo dvoryanstva XVIII–XIX vekov [Documents of church accounting of the population in the context of the genealogical culture of the Russian nobility of the 18^th and 19^th centuries]. In: Istoricheskii ezhegodnik. Sbornik nauchnykh trudov [Historic yearbook: collection of scientific articles]. Novosibirsk, Institut istorii SO RAN, 2016, pp. 4–18.
12. Leont’ev E.V. Kuptsy goroda Minusinska po materialam podatnykh revizii i ispovednykh vedomostei pervoi poloviny XIX v. [Merchants of the city of Minusinsk on the materials of the slatable audits and confessional records of the first half of the 19^th century]. In: Istoki, deyatel’nost’, nasledie: materialy tret’ei Vseros. nauch. konf. [Proc. of Rus. Sci. Conf. «Merchants of the city of Minusinsk on the materials of the slatable audits and confessional records of the first half of the 19^th century»]. Tomsk, 2019, pp. 335–342.
13. Markova M.A. Istochniki po istorii Sankt-Peterburga i stolichnoi gubernii (1730–1740 gg.) [Sources on the history of St. Petersburg and the metropolitan province (1730–1740)]. In: Materialy tserkovnoprikhodskogo ucheta naseleniya Rossii kak istoriko-demograficheskii istochnik: sbornik statei [Materials of the church-coming accounting of the population of Russia as a historical and demographic source: collection of scientific articles]. Barnaul, Altaisk University Publ., 2007, pp. 103–120.
14. Matison A.V. Prikaznye sluzhiteli Tverskoi provintsii nakanune gubernskoi reformy 1775 goda (po ispovednym vedomostyam gorodskikh prikhodov) [Order servants of the Tver province on the eve of the provincial reform of 1775 (according to the confessions of the city parishes)]. Rossiiskaya genealogiya, 2010, no. 9, pp. 293–306.
15. Mironov B.N. Ispovednye vedomosti – istochnik o chislennosti i sotsial’noi strukture pravoslavnogo naseleniya Rossii XVIII – pervoi poloviny XIX v. [Confessional statements are a source of the size and social structure of the Orthodox population of Russia in the 18^th and first half of the 19^th century]. Vspomogatel’nye istoricheskie distsipliny, 1989, vol. 20, pp. 102–117.
16. Mironov B.N. Ispovednyi i metricheskii uchet v imperskoi Rossii [Confessional and metric accounting in imperial Russia]. In: Materialy tserkovnoprikhodskogo ucheta naseleniya Rossii kak istoriko-demograficheskii istochnik: sbornik statei [Materials of the church-coming accounting of the population of Russia as a historical and demographic source: collection of scientific articles]. Barnaul, 2007, pp. 8–47.
17. Polevaya A.V. Svyashchennosluzhiteli dvortsovykh karel’skikh volostei Bezhetskogo uezda v XVIII–XIX vekakh [The Clergy of the Palace of the Karelian Volost Bezhetsk District in the XVIII–XIX centuries]. Vestnik Tverskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. Ser. Istoriya, 2019, no. 2(50), pp. 105–115.
18. Postnikov A.B. Ispovednye vedomosti kak istochnik po istorii Pskovskoi Tserkvi i dukhovenstva v 1727–1762 gg. [Confessional Records as a Source of the History of the Pskov Church and Clergy of the 1727–1762]. Vestnik Pravoslavnogo Svyato-Tikhonovskogo gumanitarnogo universiteta. Ser. 2. Istoriya. Istoriya Russkoi Pravoslavnoi tserkvi, 2016, iss. 6(73), pp. 21–44.
19. Prokhorov M.F. Krest’yanskaya sem’ya Podmoskov’ya v period Otechestvennoi voiny 1812 g.: chislennost’, sostav, struktura [The peasant family of Moscow region during the Patriotic War of 1812: numbers, composition, and structure]. Servis plus, 2015, vol. 9, no. 2, pp. 91–99.
20. Pul’kin M.V. Tainstvo pokayaniya: problema osushchestvleniya v XVIII – nachale XX vv. (po materialam Olonetskoi eparkhii) [The Sacrament of Penance: the Problems of Implementation in the XVIII – Beginning of the XX Century (based on olonetskaya diocese)]. Vestnik Leningradskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta im. A.S. Pushkina, 2010, vol. 4, no. 2, pp. 134–144.
21. Sakalo A.E. Dokumenty tserkovnogo proiskhozhdeniya XVIII v. kak istochniki istoriko-demograficheskikh issledovanii: ispovednye vedomosti [Documents of church origin of the 18th century as sources of historical and demographic research: confessional statements]. Istoricheskaya demografiya, 2011, no. 2(8), pp. 72–75.
22. Sviridov I.S. K voprosu o problemakh issledovaniya religioznosti krest’yanstva v poslednei chetverti XIX – nachale XX vv. (po materialam Tambovskoi eparkhii) [The Problems of the Study of the Peasantry Religiousness in the Last Quarter of XIX – early XX centuries revisited (based on the materials of tambov diocese)]. Nauchnye vedomosti Belgorodskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. Ser. Istoriya. Politologiya, 2018, vol. 45, no. 1, pp. 97–103.
23. Titsian A. Moskovskie prikhoda kontsa XIX – nachala XX vv.: sootnoshenie mezhdu pravoslavnymi zhitelyami goroda, uchastvovavshimi i ne uchastvovavshimi v tainstvakh ispovedi i prichastiya [Moscow Parishes in the end of the 19^th – beginning of the 20^th centuries: share of believers participating in sacraments of confession and communion among urban orthodox citizens]. Gosudarstvo, religiya, Tserkov’ v Rossii i za rubezhom, 2018, vol. 36, no. 2, pp. 315–342.
24. Fedorets A.I. Problema informatsionnoi tsennosti ispovednykh vedomostei kak istoricheskogo istochnika (na primere moskovskikh materialov XVIII v.) [The Issue of Information Value of Confessional Statements as a Historical Source (on the Basis of Moscow Written Sources, 18^th Century)]. Vestnik Moskovskogo universiteta. Ser. 8. Istoriya, 2013, no. 1, pp. 64–73.
25. Fedorets A.I. Moskovskoe kupechestvo XVIII-XIX vv. v zerkale ispovednykh vedomostei (na primere roda Tret’yakovykh) [Moscow merchant of the 18^th and 19^th centuries in the mirror of confessional statements (in the example of the Tretyakov family)]. Istoricheskii zhurnal: nauchnye issledovaniya, 2011, no. 4, pp. 42–47.
26. Feofanov A.M. Dukhovnoe soslovie i sotsial’naya mobil’nost’: fenomen «raznochintsev» kak predmet sotsial’nykh issledovanii [The Clergy and Social Mobility: the Phenomenon of «Raznochintsy» as the Subject of Social Studies]. Vestnik Pravoslavnogo Svyato-Tikhonovskogo gumanitarnogo universiteta. Ser. 2. Istoriya. Istoriya Russkoi Pravoslavnoi tserkvi, 2014, no. 5(60), pp. 139–145.
27. Khrushkaya L.N. Dokumenty po tserkovnomu uchetu naseleniya kak istochnik izucheniya voprosa o rasprostranenii staroobryadcheskoi ideologii na Arkhangel’skoi Severe [Documents on the church registration of the population as a source of study on the spread of Old Believer ideology in the Arkhangelsk North]. In: Genealogiya na Russkom Severe: memorial’naya kul’tura i rodovoe drevo Severa. Sbornik materialov mezhdunarodnoi nauchnoi konferentsii, posvyashchennoi 20-letiyu Arkhangel’skoi regional’noi obshchestvennoi organizatsii «Severnoe istoriko-rodovoe obshchestvo» [Proc. of Int. Sci. Conf. «Documents on the church registration of the population as a source of study on the spread of Old Believer ideology in the Arkhangelsk North»]. Arkhangel’sk, 2019, pp. 282–295.
28. Tsys’ O.P. Tainstva ispovedi i prichastiv v «inorodcheskikh» prikhodakh Tobol’skogo Severa (XVIII – nachalo XX vv.) [Sacraments of Confession and Communion in the «Foreign» Parishes of the Tobolsk North (XVIII – Early XX Centuries)]. Vestnik ugrovedeniya, 2020, vol. 10, no. 4, pp. 787–798.
29. Chetyrina N.A. Zagadki kuptsov Erofeevykh [Riddles of merchants of Yerofeyev]. Istoricheskii zhurnal: nauchnye issledovaniya, 2011, no. 2, pp. 76–84.
30. Chibisov M.E. Sostav naseleniya tserkovnykh prikhodov Barnaul’skogo dukhovnogo prav­le­niya v pervoi polovine XIX v. [The Composition of the Population of the Church Parishes of the barNaul Spiritual Government in the First Half of the 19^th Century]. Izvestiya Altaiskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta, 2017, no. 5(97), pp. 117–120.

Information about the author

Anzhelika N. Evdokimova – Candidate of Historical Sciences, Associate Professor, Russian History Department, Chuvash State University, Russia, Cheboksary (savelika76@mail.ru; ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0001-9030-7732).

For citations

Evdokimova A.N. THE PROBLEM OF INFORMATION VALUE OF CONFESSIONAL STATEMENTS IN HISTORICAL LITERATURE. Vestnik Chuvashskogo universiteta, 2021, no. 2, pp. 55–63. DOI: 10.47026/1810-1909-2021-2-55-63 (in Russian).

Download the full article