PEOPLE’S COMMISSARIAT OF NATIONALITIES OF THE RSFSR AND THE CREATION OF THE CRIMEAN ASSR

DOI: 10.47026/1810-1909-2022-2-75-88

УДК 93/94

ББК 63.3(2)61

Elena K. MINEEVA, Alevtina P. ZYKINA, Alexey I. MINEEV

Key words

Soviet power, national politics, People’s Commissariat of nationalities, Crimea, Autonomous Republic

Abstract

Just recently, Russia celebrated the 8^th anniversary of the return of Crimea “to its native harbor.” This important event, both for the whole country and the region, makes us once again turn to the historical fate of the Crimean Peninsula. At almost all important stages of historical development, from the time of colonization of the Northern Black Sea region by the Greeks and to the present, this region attracted the attention of all neighbors, both close and the most remote ones, which is due to the special geopolitical position of the Crimea. We can say that whoever owns the peninsula controls the entire Northern Black Sea region, and is an intermediary between Europe and the Middle East. The geographical location enables the Crimean Peninsula to play an important role as a commercial and military-political port, which also indicates the strategic importance of the region.

The years 1991 to 2008 are one of the most difficult periods in the history of Crimea. And most of the problems of the Crimean people at the turn of the XX–XXI centuries were associated with the consequences of the not fully thought-out policy of the Soviet leadership. In this regard, we consider it necessary to analyze more carefully most of the events of the Soviet Union era, since in one way or another they continue to influence modern processes. So far, a complete compromise has not yet been reached among individual active figures of the Crimean Tatar social movement and the leadership of the Republic of Crimea. History already has the experience of successfully resolving such a confrontation between representatives of the Soviet government in Crimea, on the one hand, and the Crimean Tatars in 1920-1921, on the other. As a result, the Crimean ASSR was created as part of the RSFSR. This problem has not yet received proper coverage in historiography. A certain obstacle for those wishing to be engaged in this research topic was the fact that documentary materials have long been part of the archival repositories of two states: the State Archive of the Republic of Crimea (until 2014 in Ukraine) and the State Archive of the Russian Federation. Current international events also do not contribute to an objective and impartial assessment of the problem of the formation of the Crimean Autonomy, which in October 2021 marked the 100^th anniversary of the Crimean ASSR. Despite the anniversary date, this historical event, in our opinion, has received insufficient attention and coverage in society.

In modern conditions, further study and generalization of the experience of the creation and existence of the Crimean ASSR is required. It can be useful at the current stage of the national-state development of the peninsula. The purpose of the study is to analyze the historical conditions in which the formation of national-territorial autonomy on the Crimean Peninsula took place with the active and leading role of the People’s Commissariat. The study does not pretend to be exhaustive, but makes a certain contribution to the coverage of the issue.

References

1. Bulushev Zainulla Khasainovich. Anketa otvetstvennogo rabotnika Narkomnatsa [Bulushev Zainulla Hasanovich. Questionnaire of the responsible employee of the People’s Commissariat]. Available at: http://docs.historyrussia.org/ru/nodes/85742-bulushev-zaynulla-hasainovich-anketa-otvetstvennogo-rabotnika-narkomnatsa#mode/inspect/page/1/zoom/5 (Accessed Date 2022, March 8).
2. Ves’ Krym, 1920-1925: yubileinyi sbornik [Crimea, 1920–1925: anniversary collection]. Simferopol, 1926, 572 p.
3. Vypiska iz protokola № 27 zasedaniya Prezidiuma VTsIK RSFSR «Ob obrazovanii avtonomnoi oblasti v Krymu». 12 maya 1921 g. [Extract from Protocol No. 27 of the meeting of the Presidium of the Central Executive Committee of the RSFSR “On the formation of an autonomous region in the Crimea”. May 12, 1921]. Available at: https://krym.rusarchives.ru/dokumenty/vypiska-iz-protokola-no-27-zasedaniya-prezidiuma-vcik-rsfsr-ob-obrazovanii-avtonomnoy (Accessed Date 2022, March 8).
4. Gosudarstvennyi arkhiv Rossiiskoi Federatsii. Fond R-1318 – Narodnyi komissariat po delam natsional’nostei. Opis’ 13 [State Archives of the Russian Federation. Archive R-1318. Anagraph 13].
5. Gosudarstvennyi arkhiv Rossiiskoi Federatsii. Fond R-1318 – Narodnyi komissariat po delam natsional’nostei. Opis’ 2 [State Archives of the Russian Federation. Archive R-1318. Anagraph 2].
6. Gosudarstvennyi arkhiv Rossiiskoi Federatsii. Fond R-1318 – Narodnyi komissariat po delam natsional’nostei. Opis’ 23 [State Archives of the Russian Federation. Archive R-1318. Anagraph 23].
7. Gerb s arabskoi vyaz’yu [Coat of arms with Arabic script]. Available at: https://iz.ru/1235471/arsenii-zamostianov/nashe-vse-kak-krym-stal-respublikoi (Accessed Date 2022, Feb. 23).
8. Zapiska I.V. Stalina chlenam Politbyuro TsK RKP(b) i sekretaryu TsK RKP(b) V.M. Molotovu o neobkhodimosti sozdaniya Krymskoi avtonomnoi respubliki. 29 aprelya 1921 g. [I.V. Stalin’s note to the members of the Politburo of the Central Committee of the RCP(b) and the Secretary of the Central Committee of the RCP(b) V.M. Molotov on the need to create the Crimean Autonomous Republic. April 29, 1921]. Available at: https://krym.rusarchives.ru/dokumenty/zapiska-iv-stalina-chlenam-politbyuro-ck-rkpb-i-sekretaryu-ck-rkpb-vm-molotovu-o (Accessed Date 2022, March 8).
9. Istoriya Krymskoi ASSR [History of the Crimean ASSR]. Available at: https://avdet.org/2014/03/31/istoriya-krymskoj-assr (Accessed Date 2022, Feb. 23).
10. Ishin A.V. Politiko-ekonomicheskoe polozhenie Krymskogo poluostrova v kontse 1920 – pervoi polovine 1921 g. [The political and economic situation of the Crimean Peninsula at the end of 1920 – the first half of 1921]. Available at: https://refdb.ru/look/2388430.html (Accessed Date 2022, March 8).
11. Konstitutsiya Krymskoi Sotsialisticheskoi Sovetskoi Respubliki [The Constitution of the Crimean Socialist Soviet Republic]. Available at: https://krym.rusarchives.ru/dokumenty/konstituciya-krymskoy-socialisticheskoy-sovetskoy-respubliki (Accessed Date 2022, March 8).
12. Krapiventsev M. Yu. Sekretnyi doklad predsedatelya Polnomochnoi komissii TsIK i SNK RSFSR po delam Kryma Sh.N. Ibragimova: tekst i kommentarii [Secret report of the Chairman of the Plenipotentiary Commission of the CEC and the SNK of the RSFSR on Crimean affairs Sh.N. Ibragimov: text and commentary]. Available at: http://www.msusevastopol.net/downloads/prich2011/prich–b.pdf (Accessed Date 2022, March 8).
13. Krapiventsev M.Yu. Istoriya transformatsii politiko-pravovogo statusa Kryma v 1917–1921: dis. … kand. ist. nauk godakh [The history of the transformation of the political and legal status of the Crimea in 1917–1921. Cand. Diss.]. Sevastopol, 2014, 231
14. Mineeva E.K. Narkomnats RSFSR: tseli, zadachi, struktura [People’s Commissariat of the RSFSR: goals, objectives, structure]. Vestnik Chuvashskogo universiteta, 2006, 7, pp. 23–33.
15. Mineeva E.K., Zykina A.P. Deyatel’nost’ Narkomnatsa RSFSR po sozdaniyu natsional’nykh avtonomii [Activities of the People’s Commissariat of the RSFSR on the creation of national autonomies]. Vestnik Chuvashskogo universiteta, 2021, 4, pp. 92–105.
16. Obrashchenie Krymskogo revkoma i Krymskogo obkoma v TsK RKP(b) s zaprosom o direktivakh. 6 yanvarya 1921 g. [The appeal of the Crimean Revkom and the Crimean Regional Committee to the Central Committee of the RCP(b) with a request for directives. January 6, 1921]. Available at: https://krym.rusarchives.ru/dokumenty/obrashchenie-krymskogo-revkoma-i-krymskogo-obkoma-v-ck-rkpb-s-zaprosom-o-direktivah (Accessed Date 2022, March 8).
17. Postanovlenie Politbyuro TsK RKP(b) o priznanii «zhelatel’nym sozdaniya Krymskoi sovetskoi respubliki». 23 aprelya 1919 g. [Resolution of the Politburo of the Central Committee of the RCP (b) on the recognition of the “desirable creation of the Crimean Soviet Republic.” April 23, 1919]. Available at: https://krym.rusarchives.ru/dokumenty/postanovlenie-politbyuro-ck-rkpb-o-priznanii-zhelatelnym-sozdaniya-krymskoy-sovetskoy (Accessed Date 2022, March 8).
18. Protokol’noe postanovlenie Plenuma TsK RKP(b) «Ob ispravlenii postanovleniya Politbyuro TsK RKP(b) ot 30 aprelya ob obrazovanii avtonomnoi Krymskoi respubliki» 18 maya 1921 g. [Protocol Resolution of the Plenum of the Central Committee of the RCP(b) “On correcting the resolution of the Politburo of the Central Committee of the RCP (b) of April 30 on the formation of the Autonomous Crimean Republic” on May 18, 1921]. Available at: https://krym.rusarchives.ru/dokumenty/protokolnoe-postanovlenie-plenuma-ck-rkpb-ob-ispravlenii-postanovleniya-politbyuro-ck-rkpb (Accessed Date 2022, March 8).
19. Protokol’noe postanovlenie Politbyuro KTs RKP(b) «O sozdanii avtonomnoi oblasti v Krymu». 30 aprelya 1921 g. [Protocol resolution of the Politburo of the CC RCP(b) “On the creation of an autonomous region in the Crimea”. April 30, 1921]. Available at: https://krym.rusarchives.ru/dokumenty/protokolnoe-postanovlenie-politbyuro-ck-rkpb-o-sozdanii-avtonomnoy-oblasti-v-krymu-p-3 (Accessed Date 2022, March 8).
20. Protokol’noe postanovlenie Politbyuro TsK RKP(b) «Podtverzhdenie postanovleniya TsK ob obrazovanii Krymskoi respubliki». 24 maya 1921 g. [Protocol resolution of the Politburo of the Central Committee of the RCP(b) “Confirmation of the resolution of the Central Committee on the formation of the Crimean Republic”. May 24, 1921]. Available at: https://krym.rusarchives.ru/dokumenty/protokolnoe-postanovlenie-politbyuro-ck-rkpb-podtverzhdenie-postanovleniya-ck-ob (Accessed Date 2022, March 8).
21. Protokol’noe postanovlenie Politbyuro TsK RKP(b) ob izmenenii postanovleniya Orgbyuro TsK VKP(b) «O sostave Krymskogo revkoma». 15 noyabrya 1920 g. [Protocol resolution of the Politburo of the Central Committee of the RCP (b) on changing the resolution of the Organizational Bureau of the Central Committee of the CPSU (b) “On the composition of the Crimean Revolutionary Committee”. November 15, 1920]. Available at: https://krym.rusarchives.ru/dokumenty/protokolnoe-postanovlenie-politbyuro-ck-rkpb-ob-izmenenii-postanovleniya-orgbyuro-ck-vkpb (Accessed Date 2022, March 8).
22. Protokol’noe postanovlenie Soveta narodnykh komissarov RSFSR «O sozdanii avtonomnoi oblasti v Krymu». 10 maya. 1921 g. [Protocol Resolution of the Council of People’s Commissars of the RSFSR “On the creation of an autonomous region in the Crimea”. May 10, 1921]. Available at: https://krym.rusarchives.ru/dokumenty/protokolnoe-postanovlenie-soveta-narodnyh-komissarov-rsfsr-o-sozdanii-avtonomnoy-oblasti-v (Accessed Date 2022, March 8).
23. Rossiiskii gosudarstvennyi arkhiv sotsial’no-politicheskoi istorii. Fond 17. Opis’ 13 [Russian State Archives of Socio-Political History. Archive 17. Anagraph 13].
24. Sultan-Galiev M.Kh. Izbrannye trudy [Selected works]. Kazan, Gasyr , 1998, 719 p.
25. Usov S. Istoriko-ekonomicheskie ocherki Kryma: proshloe i nastoyashchee krymskogo sel’skogo khozyaistva [Historical and economic sketches of the Crimea: the past and present of Crimean agriculture]. Simferopol, 1925, 319
26. Kharabuga V. K probleme gosudarstvenno-pravovogo statusa Krymskoi ASSR (1921–1945 gg.) [On the problem of the State-legal status of the Crimean ASSR (1921–1945)]. Available at: http://www.ruscrimea.ru/2014/03/29/3527.htm (Accessed Date 2022, Feb. 23).
27. Khayali R.I. Organizatsiya i provedenie politiki korenizatsii: praktika Krymskoi ASSR (1920–1930-e gody) [Organization and implementation of the Korenization policy: the Practice of the Crimean ASSR (1920–1930s)]. Available at: https://human.snauka.ru/2017/05/23818 (Accessed Date 2021, Nov. 3).
28. Khayali R.I. Ocherki istorii obshchestvenno-politicheskoi i kul’turnoi zhizni krymskikh tatar v XX veke [Essays on the history of the socio-political and cultural life of the Crimean Tatars in the XX century]. Simferopol’, Dolya , 2008, 512 p.
29. Khayali R.I. Politicheskie partii krymskikh tatar (1917–1928 gg.) [Political parties of the Crimean Tatars (1917–1928)]. Available at: https://human.snauka.ru/2017/03/23009 (Accessed Date 2021, Nov. 3).
30. Shest’ let natsional’noi politiki sovetskoi vlasti i Narkomnats 1917–1923 gg. (Vmesto otcheta) [Six years of the national policy of the Soviet government and the People’s Commissariat of 1917–1923 (Instead of the report)]. Moscow, Narkomnats Publ., 1924, 229 p.

Information about the authors

Elena K. Mineeva – Doctor of Historical Sciences, Professor, Russian History Department, Chuvash State University, Cheboksary, Russia (mineevaek21@mail.ru; ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0001-8301-9951).

Alevtina P. Zykina – Candidate of Pedagogical Sciences, Associate Professor, Russian History Department, Chuvash State University, Cheboksary, Russia (alevtina-pet@mail.ru; ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0003-3486-706X).

Alexey I. Mineev – Candidate of Historical Sciences, Head of the 1C Research and Training Center, Leader Soft – Implementation Center LLC, Cheboksary, Russia (minalig@inbox.ru; ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0001-5791-6210).

For citations

Mineeva E.K., Zykina A.P., Mineev A.I. PEOPLE’s COMMISSARIAT OF NATIONALITIES OF THE RSFSR AND THE CREATION OF THE CRIMEAN ASSR. Vestnik Chuvashskogo universiteta, 2022, no. 2, pp. 75–88. DOI: 10.47026/1810-1909-2022-2-75-88 (in Russian).

Download the full article